Season 2 of The Buccaneers kicks off with serious drama. Nan St. George shock marries Duke Theo, not because she loves him, but to protect her sister Jinny from her abusive husband. The move throws everything into chaos and suddenly Nan is pulled into the rigid world of English high society, surrounded by people who want her to smile, obey, and behave. Theo has no idea she’s still in love with Guy Thwarte, and while he’s busy playing the devoted husband, Nan is trying to figure out how to survive a life she never wanted. The dowager duchess is icy and controlling, making it crystal clear that Nan’s real job is to fall in line.
But Nan has no intention of being anyone’s perfect duchess. At a major society ball, she shows up in a stunning red dress that turns every head in the room. It’s not just a fashion statement—it’s her way of shifting attention away from Jinny, who’s secretly run off with Guy. That moment is a power play, full of confidence and quiet rebellion, and Kristine Frøseth nails every beat. Her performance is subtle and strong, filled with tension that simmers just under the surface.
Then comes the twist. Nell, introduced as Patti’s sister, is actually Nan’s birth mother. Leighton Meester’s arrival is a total game-changer. Her scenes with Nan are charged and emotional, and you can feel the walls starting to close in around Nan as everything she thought she knew about her past gets upended. It’s messy, painful, and adds a whole new layer to Nan’s identity crisis.
The supporting cast gets their own moments too. Conchita steps up in a big way as Richard’s father falls ill, managing finances and showing she’s more than just a glamorous outsider. Lizzy starts to fall for Hector, and while it’s still early, there’s chemistry there that could definitely stir things up. Mabel and Honoria’s relationship continues to unfold quietly, with moments that feel tender and real, even in the face of society’s judgment. Jinny and Guy aren’t around much this episode, but their decision to escape lingers heavily, especially since Nan is keeping their secret.
This episode feels more mature than anything in season one. The tone is a bit heavier, but in a good way. The show isn’t afraid to explore the emotional fallout of these women’s choices. It’s less about shiny dresses and flirtation, more about consequence, loyalty, and figuring out who you are when the world tries to define it for you. The writing is sharper, the performances more grounded, and the entire vibe feels richer. Nan’s journey is just getting started, and if this first episode is any sign, we’re in for a deeper, bolder season.
The Buccaneers season 2 is now airing on AppleTV+.
