Review: The Five-Star Weekend - Season 1


The Five-Star Weekend feels like the perfect series to settle in with when you're craving an emotional drama wrapped in stunning coastal scenery. Based on Elin Hilderbrand's bestselling novel, Peacock's latest series is equal parts friendship drama, family story and beachside escape, making it an easy show to lose yourself in.

Jennifer Garner is the heart of the series as Hollis Shaw, a hugely successful food influencer whose carefully curated life is turned upside down after the sudden death of her husband. Garner gives one of her most heartfelt performances in years, bringing warmth, vulnerability and quiet strength to a character who is trying to figure out what life looks like after unimaginable loss. You feel every step of Hollis's journey without the series ever becoming too heavy.

Looking for a fresh start, Hollis invites one friend from every chapter of her life to spend a weekend together at her stunning Nantucket home. It sounds like the perfect reset, but it doesn't take long before old wounds, hidden secrets and years of unresolved tension begin bubbling to the surface. Every guest arrives carrying their own emotional baggage, and watching those stories collide is what makes the series so addictive.

The cast is packed with talent. Regina Hall is fantastic as the fiercely driven Dru-Ann, while Chloƫ Sevigny brings years of shared history and quiet emotion to Hollis's oldest friendship. D'Arcy Carden shines here as she continues to prove she can handle drama just as effortlessly as comedy, and Gemma Chan gives Gigi an intriguing sense of mystery that keeps you wanting to know more. Timothy Olyphant adds plenty of charm as Hollis's former love, slipping naturally into the story and giving it another emotional layer.

One of the show's biggest strengths is the way it captures female friendships. These relationships feel lived in, complicated and completely believable. Some friends know exactly which buttons to push, others have drifted apart over the years, and some are only just discovering who the other person really is. The conversations feel genuine, the conflicts never seem forced and the emotional payoffs land beautifully. I wish we got more shows like this.

Nantucket is every bit as dreamy as you would hope. Beautiful beaches, charming streets and breathtaking coastal homes create the perfect backdrop for a story about healing, reconnecting and finding your way again. The location isn't just there to look pretty either. It gives the entire series a relaxed, summery atmosphere that makes every episode feel like a mini getaway.

Fans of the book will recognise the heart of the story, although the series isn't afraid to shake things up. Some of the biggest twists arrive in different ways, supporting characters get more room to grow and several storylines have been expanded to make the ensemble feel even stronger. The changes feel natural and help the story work beautifully on screen.

The writing keeps things moving with a great mix of heartfelt moments, family drama, romance and just enough mystery to keep you clicking "next episode." Every chapter reveals something new about these women, showing that nobody's life is quite as perfect as it appears from the outside. Watching them slowly lower their walls and reconnect with themselves and each other is both emotional and deeply satisfying.

The Five-Star Weekend is exactly the kind of comfort drama that's easy to recommend. It has an incredible cast, beautiful locations, layered characters and plenty of emotional moments without ever forgetting to be entertaining. Whether you're already a fan of Elin Hilderbrand's novels or simply looking for your next character-driven binge, this is one weekend you'll be glad you accepted the invitation to. While this is billed as a limited series, I'd love to see a season 2.

The Five-Star Weekend is available now on Peacock.